Why doesn't the water spill when the bucket is upside down?

Swing a bucket of water in a big circle over your head and — somehow — it pours nothing on you, even at the very top. Gravity is still pulling. So what's holding the water in? Let's find out… by trying to make it spill.

1Two things that are always true

Gravity pulls down. Circles pull inward.

You only need these two ideas. Watch each one wiggle:

Gravity never quits

Gravity pulls everything straight down — always. It does not turn off when the bucket flips upside down. At the top of the loop, it's still tugging the water toward the ground.

Circles need an inward yank

To curve in a circle, something must yank you toward the center the whole time. Let go and you shoot off in a straight line. The faster you spin, the harder that inward yank has to be.

2Two ways to swing

The lazy loop vs the speedy loop

The lazy loop

Swing slow and gentle

To keep curving slowly, the water only needs a tiny inward pull — smaller than gravity. But gravity is still pulling down full strength, so there's more downward pull than the circle needs. Hold that thought — what do you think that extra pull does to the water at the top?

The speedy loop

Swing fast and hard

Now keeping the water curving needs a big inward pull — at least as big as gravity. Swing just barely fast enough and gravity alone is exactly that pull; swing faster and the bucket pushes inward too. We'll see in a second what that does to the water.

3Your turn — be the arm

Swing the bucket and watch the two pulls

Drag the slider to swing the bucket faster or slower. Watch the two force bars at the top of the loop: amber is how hard the water needs to be yanked inward to keep curving, slate is gravity pulling down. When amber reaches slate, gravity is exactly the inward pull the circle needs. (Don't worry about the water yet — that comes next.)

Swing speed a gentle swing
SLOWFAST

At the top of the loop

Inward yank needed
Gravity pulling down

4Now try to make it spill

Find the speed where it flips

There's a speed where the water goes from "stays in" to "pours out." Before you go hunting for it — make a call.

Guess before you find out

To keep the water from spilling at the very top of the loop, do you need to swing the bucket faster or slower?